Will big data algorithms dismantle the foundations of liberalism

In Homo Deus, Yuval Noah Harari argues that technological advances of the twenty-first century will usher in a significant shift in how humans make important life decisions. Instead of turning to the Bible or the Quran, to the heart or to our therapists, parents, and mentors, people will turn to Big Data recommendation algorithms to make these choices for them. Much as we rely on Spotify to recommend music to us, we will soon rely on algorithms to decide our careers, spouses, and commitments. Harari also predicts that next, the state will take away individuals’ rights to make their own choices about their lives. If Google knows where your children would flourish best in school, why should the state allow a fallible human parent to decide? Liberalism—which, as Harari uses this term, refers to a state of society in which human freedom to choose is respected and championed—will collapse. In this paper, I argue that Harari’s conception of the future implications of recommendation algorithms is deeply flawed, for two reasons. First, users will not rely on algorithms to make decisions for them because they have no reason to trust algorithms, which are developed by companies with their own incentives, such as profit. Second, for most of our life decisions, algorithms will not be able to be developed, because the factors relevant to the decisions we face are unique to our situation. I present an alternative depiction of the future: instead of relying on algorithms to make decisions for us, humans will use algorithms to enhance our decision-making by helping us consider the most relevant choices first and notice information we might not otherwise. Finally, I will also argue that even if computers could make many of our decisions for us, liberalism as a political system would emerge unscathed.

Data and Resources
To access the resources you must log in
  • BibTex filebibtex

    The resource: 'BibTex file' is not accessible as guest user. You must login to access it!
  • Journal ArticleHTML

    The resource: 'Journal Article' is not accessible as guest user. You must login to access it!
Additional Info
Field Value
Creator First, Daniel
DOI 10.1007/s00146-017-0733-4
Group e-Learning
Publisher Springer
Source AI & Society
Thematic Cluster Privacy Enhancing Technology [PET]
system:type JournalArticle
Management Info
Field Value
Version 1
Last Updated 5 April 2021, 18:04 (CEST)
Created 5 April 2021, 17:42 (CEST)